Plastic
Plastic threads rest on a coral reef off the coast of Wakatobi National Park, Indonesia.

SHARM EL-SHEIKH, EGYPT – As global delegations fight to keep the dream of limiting warming to 1.5C within reach, plastic pollution contaminating aquatic life, soil quality and the human body, is skyrocketing.

The relentless growth of demand for plastics driven by subsidies for fossil fuels, coupled with the failure of recycling and waste management systems to keep pace, has set a trajectory whereby plastics consumption will account for 20% of global oil and gas consumption by 2050.

“One million plastic bottles are consumed every minute,” Ecuadorian Environment Minister Gustavo Manrique Miranda told COP27 delegates at a United Nations (UN) Conference on Trade and Development on Thursday. “By the end of our meeting, the world will have consumed 60 million bottles.”

Plastics consumption quadrupled over the past 30 years

Plastics

In the past 30 years, plastic consumption has quadrupled to reach 460 million tons in 2019. Global production of recycled plastics has more than quadrupled in this same period to 29.1 megatons per year, but this represents just 6% of global plastics production. The other 94% are ‘virgin’ plastics made new from crude oil or gas, according to the OECD.

Unrecycled plastics compound the environmental impacts of their production. Of the plastics that don’t get reprocessed and reused, 19% are incinerated, 50% end up in landfills, and 22% end up being burned in open pits, wind up in uncontrolled dumpsites, or scattered along roadsides, farmland or the waters of poorer countries.

“I don’t think the magnitude of the connection between climate and plastics can be overstated,” said Susan Garder, director of the ecosystems division at the UN Environmental Programme (UNEP). 

“The world is trying to and must decrease emissions by 45% by 2030 to keep the dream of 1.5C alive, and we’re seeing plastics move in the opposite direction.”

Plastics’ health impacts not well documented, but warning lights are flashing 

Microplastics were detected in human blood for the first time this year, heightening research efforts to understand their effects on our health.

Since its invention in the 1950s, the world has produced as much as ten billion tons of plastic, most of which still exists today. The gradual breakdown and dispersal of most of that plastic material over time has led to the shedding of chemicals and microplastics, which are now ubiquitous in the bodies of terrestrial wildlife, oceans and fisheries.

A 2021 report by the Food and Agriculture Organization (FAO) found that plastic contamination of farmland from single-use soil and plant coverings, tubing and other materials, poses an increasing threat to soil quality, food safety and human health. 

On the seas, a recent Nature study found that the blue whales, which typically feed upon krill, may consume some 10 million pieces of microplastics a day, a taste of what other large fish like tuna and salmon are likely eating as well.

The fact that human exposure to plastic additives such as DEHP and Phthalates, used to soften polyvinyl chloride (PVC), leads to higher risks of cancer and hormonal disorders that cause reproductive health problems is well documented.  

Along with its uses in waterproof garments and building materials, PVC is ubiquitous in healthcare settings where it is a key component of basic medical devices like IV tubes. Not only are the phthalate additives health harmful, but the production of PVC out of fossil fuel-derived ethylene, also generates considerable mercury emissions toxic to humans and to wildlife.

Plastics
Unrecycled plastics have knock-on effects on the environment, emissions, biodiversity, and human health.

During the COVID pandemic, the healthcare sector, already heavily reliant on all sorts of plastics, doubled down on their use as single-use masks and protective gear became the norm for infection prevention, while pollution concerns were put on the backburner.

Studies of the health effects of broader classes of microplastics are still in their infancy, but early findings have triggered alarm bells in the medical community.

A 2020 study conducted by a team of Portuguese researchers linked plastics exposure to chronic inflammation and the development of neoplasms, or tissue abnormalities (neoplasia), that may be carcinogenic. 

“Exposure may occur by ingestion, inhalation and dermal contact due to the presence of microplastics in products, foodstuff and air,” the report found.

“In all biological systems, microplastic exposure may cause particle toxicity, with oxidative stress, inflammatory lesions and increased uptake or translocation. The inability of the immune system to remove synthetic particles may lead to chronic inflammation and increased risk of neoplasia. Furthermore, microplastics may release their constituents, adsorbed contaminants and pathogenic organisms.”

And as microplastic pollution was detected in human blood for the first time in March of this year, with scientists finding the tiny particles in nearly 80% of the people tested, a review of 17 studies published in the Journal of Hazardous Materials in 2021 found evidence that ingested microplastics can trigger cell death, allergic responses, and damage to cell walls.

“We are exposed to these particles every day: we’re eating them, we’re inhaling them, and we don’t really know how they react with our bodies once they are in,” Evangelos Danopoulos, the first author of the review told the Guardian. “We should be concerned. Right now, there isn’t really a way to protect ourselves.”

Plastics are destroying oceans’ ability to absorb carbon

By 2050, our oceans are projected to contain more plastics than fish.

Along with the direct effects of plastics on health, their proliferation is also destroying the ocean’s ability to absorb carbon.

Our oceans, like the Amazon Rainforest or Africa’s Congo Basin, are “carbon sinks”, Nicholas Hardman-Mountford, Head of Oceans and Natural Resources of the Commonwealth Secretariat explained at the COP27 side event. 

Oceans absorb more carbon from the atmosphere than they release, making them critical to the balance of our climate, and any hopes of limiting the increase in temperature of the planet.

By 2050, projections show that our oceans may contain more plastics than fish. These will not only suffocate marine life, but also phytoplankton, the microorganisms at the heart of oceans’ abilities to absorb carbon dioxide, as forests and plants do on dry land. 

As millions of tons of plastic break down in oceans across the world, the resulting microplastics infiltrate the phytoplankton, damaging their ability to carbon capture by blocking sunlight, and preventing the process of photosynthesis.

This “biological carbon pump” transfers about 10 gigatons of carbon from the atmosphere to the deep seas every year, according to NASA’s Earth Observatory.

“The oceans have taken up a third of the carbon dioxide we put into the atmosphere since the start of the Industrial Revolution,” said Hardman-Mountford.

“If we damage that carbon sink, we are just making the atmospheric problem even worse.” 

Oil and gas subsidies fueling plastic boom 

Fossil fuel subsidies by percentage of global GDP, per the IMF.

Fossil fuel subsidies have taken center stage at COP27, and for good reason. These subsidies, amounting to some $5.9 trillion in 2020, are widely known to drive countries’ continued addiction to coal, oil and gas, but a crucial detail is often absent: they are artificially deflating the price of plastics. 

Global fossil fuel subsidies almost doubled in 2021, and the International Monetary Fund projects they will continue to grow to 7.4% of GDP in 2025, up from 6.8% in 2020. Accordingly, the UNEP Emissions Gap report found that global emissions in 2022 likely broke the all-time record set by the world in 2019, leaving “no credible path” to keeping temperature rise under 1.5° C.

WTO has begun to take heed of the fossil fuels subsidy issue – just barely

Ngozi Okonjo-Iweala, Director of the World Trade Organization, speaking on a WTO panel at COP27 in Egypt.

The World Trade Organization (WTO) has recently taken heed of the damage fossil fuel subsidies are doing to the climate, a shift attested to in their report on Trade and Climate released earlier this week at COP27.

WTO members have only just begun discussing the fossil fuel subsidy issue informally, with a small subset of 44 countries signing onto a statement calling for the phaseout of “inefficient fossil fuel subsidies”. But these subsidies are an important form of income support for the poor in many developing countries, and their reduction can, and has in the past, provoked civil unrest in the past.

Adding to the political complexity is the fact that the WTO rules are extremely lax on the kinds of fossil fuel subsidies that can be doled out to consumers.  However, the rules contain strict limitations on governments’ provision of subsidies to favor local manufacture of goods such as solar panels – since such subsidies are seen as discriminatory and thus a barrier to free trade.

In the past, for example, governments such as India that tried to invest in renewable energy by enacting “local content” requirements to jump-start the development of local green industries, as well as jobs and social benefits, lost cases in the global trade fora brought by rich countries such as the United States.

But paradoxically, by the same WTO rules, a government can invest in fossil fuel production deals with a big multinational to create a domestic fossil fuels industry – which generates long-term economic benefits in the form of cheaper domestic fuels along with income on exports for years to come.  So the built-in biases of trade rules, not to mention capital flows, still heavily favor fossil fuels development.

Plastics lost in the shuffle of free trade rules

Lost in the shuffle is the impact these free-trade rules also have on the production of plastics. Because plastics are produced from the by-products of both natural gas and crude oil refining, a subsidy for fossil fuels is a subsidy for plastics. 

Like fossil fuels, the current boom in plastics consumption is being driven primarily by growth in emerging markets.  And without rectification of the basic economic incentives driving the subsidized production and use of plastics, consumer behavior is unlikely to change.

Projected impacts of fossil fuel subsidy reform on carbon dioxide emissions.

While environment ministers agreed in March to negotiate a treaty on plastics pollution, the negotiations will likely take years, and will not have an effect on market dynamics in the near-term. 

“You have a very cheap product because the fuel is cheap. And why is the fuel cheap? Because it is subsidized,” said Aik Hoe Lim, director of the WTO’s Trade and Environment division. 

“If the subsidies for fossil fuels do not change, the economics [for reducing plastics] don’t work out. Production will continue to flow unless this very basic economic question is addressed,” Lim said.

With the world hurtling beyond the 1.5C ceiling at lightning speed, any hopes of stopping at this target will depend on a reversal in the plastics boom. Otherwise, as panelists repeatedly noted, plastics will not only represent one-fifth of oil and gas production by 2040, but by 2050, plastics will represent one-tenth of the planet´s entire available “budget” of carbon emissions from all sources – including not only fossil fuels burning but also from food and medicines production, building construction, waste management, and other emissions-generating activities essential to life as we know it. 

“The production and incineration emissions from plastics currently sit at around 850 million tons of greenhouse gas per year – that’s equivalent to nearly 190 500-megawatt coal-fired power stations,” said Hardman-Mountford.

“By 2030, it will be 300 power stations. And by 2050, it will be 10% of the carbon budget we have left to remain under 1.5C.”

Image Credits: QPhia, Plastic Soup Foundation, University of Oregon, IMF.

TRIPS Waiver protest in Indonesia. Civil society protested globally against the delay and destruction of the TRIPS waiver.

Deadlock may once again be the name of the game at the World Trade Organization’s (WTO’s) Council for Trade-Related Aspects of Intellectual Property Rights—TRIPS, for short.

A communication from Switzerland and Mexico questioning the need to extend the waiver on intellectual property rights on COVID-19 vaccines to therapeutics and diagnostics is laying bare the divergences and complexities of one of the most contentious issues facing the organization. 

Readers may remember that the 12th Ministerial Conference (MC12) was hailed as a major success: “The WTO is back,” claimed, in essence, headlines around the world. In the wee hours of a sunny Geneva morning on 17 June, as bleary-eyed delegates concluded their work, they announced, among other agreements, a deal on conditionally waiving patents on COVID-19 vaccines. 

While marking a true milestone in negotiations which had begun in 2020, when India and South Africa introduced a text demanding such a waiver, the agreement, made after intense negotiations, was narrower in scope than the original proposal. If the WTO could claim success, in reality the agreement satisfied no one: its proponents, health activists, and civil society rejected it as too limited, while Big Pharma had fought tooth and nail to prevent any waiver agreement at all.

The June agreement explicitly called for the vaccine waiver to be extended to the “production and distribution of COVID-19 diagnostics and therapeutics” within six months of adoption, setting the deadline for passage of an agreement to December 19—the first business day after 17 December.

With less than six weeks remaining, time is running out. “The level of urgency within the WTO to reach consensus on this issue is difficult to assess,” according to global health writer Priti Patnaik, author of a newly published book on the subject. “A range of countries remain undecided and have sought more information. It is not even clear whether the proponents will go the last mile to fight for this.”

Informal discussions about the extension were held in September but led nowhere. 

Rising concerns

 In a meeting last week in Geneva, the chair of the TRIPS Council, Ambassador Lansana Gberie of Sierra Leone, said that the absence, at this late stage, of concrete, text-based proposals on the issue of the extension is “very concerning,” and urged delegations to explore all options to make progress.

The ambassador will begin reaching out to individual members in the coming weeks to look for areas of possible convergence. South Africa, co-sponsor of the initial waiver proposal, also reported that its delegation has recently been holding bilateral contacts to try to find a way through the impasse.

The only document put forward so far has been a communication submitted on 1 November by Mexico and Switzerland, which does not represent a formal negotiating position. It does, however, raise questions about the ability of the trade body to meet its objective of reaching an agreement by mid-December.

In essence, the Swiss and Mexican communication uses the same rationale already advanced by Switzerland when opposing a waiver for COVID-19 vaccines at the height of the pandemic: a waiver would not, argued Switzerland and its pharmaceutical industry, along with a number of Western countries, accelerate the rate of vaccination in the world, because the main problem lies, the industry claimed, in the manufacturing and distribution of the newly developed vaccines. 

 Today, the two countries write, the same argument can be made, even if in this case, the problem is not one of scarcity but of a surplus of available therapeutics and diagnostics: “No shortage of therapeutics exists. Instead, large parts of innovators’ production capacity remain idle due to lack of demand. […] This involves issues with logistics and distribution, which are not IP-related, but that need to be addressed.”

Three ‘camps’

Diplomatic sources close to the negotiations say that as it stands now, governments are broadly divided into three groups:

  • Those who favor the extension of the waiver to include therapeutics and diagnostics include South Africa, India, Kenya, Indonesia, Zimbabwe, Pakistan, Egypt, Bolivia, Argentina, Venezuela, and the African, Caribbean and Pacific Group of states.
  • Countries questioning the need for an extension include Switzerland, Singapore, Japan, Canada, South Korea, the European Union, and the United Kingdom.
  • A third group, consisting of Colombia, Costa Rica, Uruguay, Mexico, China and Chinese Taipei, is considering a compromise solution; a limited extension to include a specific list of therapeutic and diagnostic products. Today, over 1,800 COVID-19 therapeutics are currently in different stages of the R&D pipeline.

The joint Swiss–Mexican letter notes that 138 bilateral voluntary licensing agreements with 127 countries have resulted in the creation of 191 production sites for COVID-19 therapeutics worldwide. Based on this information, the communication states, “we do not face a situation where we have an IP-induced lack of access to or a lack of manufacturing capacity of COVID-19 therapeutics and diagnostics. As a consequence, no adjustments to the IP system seem to be required.”

 However, these arguments have so far failed to sway the proponents of a broad waiver as initially proposed by India and South Africa. “The European Union, Switzerland, and the United Kingdom are playing a cynical game of running down the clock in WTO negotiations on extending the [MC12 TRIPS agreement] to diagnostics and therapeutics,” said Thiru Balasubramaniam, Geneva representative of Knowledge Ecology International.

Balasubramaniam also noted that just this week, WHO’s Director-General, Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus, said that “one of the most important lessons of the pandemic is that manufacturing capacity for medicines, diagnostics, vaccines and other tools is concentrated in too few countries.” 

For Balasubramaniam, “WTO members expressing doubts about the barriers posed by intellectual property with respect to accessing COVID-19 therapeutics and diagnostics should pay heed to the advice of the World Health Organization, the leading authority on global health.”

The TRIPS Council will meet again, informally, on 22 November. “We do not have a lot of time,” the chairperson acknowledges. Further meetings are scheduled for 6 December, with the possibility of calling members for another meeting on December 15, four days before the deadline.

Additional reporting by Philippe Mottaz.

This article was first published by the Geneva Observer.

Image Credits: Raja Mataniari .

Kenya’s draft family policy aims to discourage divorce without regard for women in abusive relationships.

Newly elected Kenyan President William Ruto has made his position on critical human rights issues such as safe abortion and LGBTQ rights clear over many years – and now,  by including a controversial  “family protection policy” in his first executive order, he is likely to promote a narrow definition of family that stigmatises anyone who is not part of a nuclear family.

 After the August elections, anti-rights groups started to clamour for the Department of Labour and Social Protection to revive the 2019 National Policy on Family Promotion and Protection that was drafted by an isolated handful of individuals devoid of public participation. This draft was not signed into policy and hence never implemented.

With the passage of his first Executive Order, the President has now responded with a thumbs-up, indicating that establishing a family policy is one of his priority areas.

Narrow, nuclear definition of ‘family’

The wording of the draft policy is problematic. It promotes an extremely narrow Western definition of a nuclear family and stigmatises all other families – including women-headed households, families born through surrogates, polygamous families and same-sex couples. This exclusion goes against the very values that the Presidency has always espoused as a Christian.

Kenyan families, like most African families, cannot be boxed into neat nuclear definitions. Many of us are descendants of polygamous grandparents, with a huge collection of blood relatives and family members who were taken into our household after wars, drought, HIV or adopted after the death of a parent.

While other African countries such as Rwanda, Ethiopia and South Africa have “family and social protection” policies, their versions protect vulnerable members of family and community from injustices arising from oppressive social structures. Yet the proposed draft policy on family seeks to promote the exclusionary, conservative Christian model of the family, prevent divorce, and disregard other family models. 

By asserting that “family cohesion is founded on the unity of spouses”, the draft stigmatizes and excludes single-parent families and divorced people. By defining marriage as being between “two persons of the opposite sex”, it excludes polygamous and same-sex partnerships, which are amongst us whether we like it or not.

“The primary function of the family is to ensure the continuation of society, biologically through procreation and to promote and emphasize marriage preparation,” according to the policy. Such statements already isolate child-free couples! It also identifies “the key policy issues” as being related to “ensuring that the family that emerges from marriages becomes a true foundation for social order in Kenya”.

Priority of ‘preventing divorce’ ignores abuse in marriage

Kenyan Olympics runner Agnes Tirop died after being stabbed multiple times, and her husband has since been arrested.

The document prioritizes “preventing divorce” by any means necessary, including alternative dispute resolution, but this culture known as “vumilia ndoa” does not recognise the vulnerability of women and children in abusive marriages. Contrary to the Marriage Act, the policy discourages divorce as a valid solution and prioritizes “protecting the union” over protecting the women in abusive marriages.

The recent murders of Olympic bronze medallist, runner Agnes Tirop, allegedly after she had resolved to divorce her abusive husband, and athlete Edith Muthoni  – and the subsequent arrest of their partners – have taught the nation that we must prioritize safety over marriage.

Violence has been normalised in the country, with 42% of women aged 15-49 years considering that a husband is justified in beating his wife in certain instances, according to research.

 

Regionally, the draft does not match up to the African Union’s 2004 Plan of Action on the Family in Africa, which requires member states to create a conducive environment for ALL family members to thrive.

Compared to other countries’ policies, Kenya’s draft offers no practical help – no income support services, child day care, no campaigns against domestic violence, no promotion of gender equality, or the extension of economic and social opportunities to women. So the policy’s intention appears simply to identify those that are worthy of protection and those that are not – based on a discriminatory view of the family.

Unless the text of the 2019 version of the family protection policy is revised, the current draft will subject more women to violent marriages, further stigmatise divorce, and exclude the diverse relationships of so many of our families.

Tabitha Saoyo is a feminist human rights lawyer. She draws inspiration for this article from her own past experiences working on the complexities of marriage and divorce as a former International Federation of Women Lawyers (FIDA) Programs Officer. She is a board member of Amnesty International (Kenya).

 

 

Nerima Were is a feminist and human rights activist, and an advocate of the High Court in Kenya. She is the Deputy Executive Director at the Kenya Legal and Ethical Issues Network on HIV & AIDS (KELIN), as well as a tutorial fellow and doctoral candidate at the University of Nairobi.

The Rosa Luxemburg Foundation provided support for this article.

Vials of Pfizer´s COVID-19 vaccine; vaccines mostly reached countries in same region they were produced, WHO report finds.

The World Health Organization (WHO) has urged governments worldwide to step up the supervision of vaccine manufacture and distribution, especially when public funding is used in vaccine R&D or manufacture, so as to prioritise essential vaccines and ensure they are distributed equitably. 

The global health agency’s call to governments came as it released its annual Vaccine Market Report on Wednesday. It also pressed for countries to agree on stronger rules for the more equitable global distribution of vaccines. 

“WHO is calling on governments around the world to expand research and manufacturing outside its traditional centers to increase investment in an oversight of vaccine manufacturing and distribution, especially for vaccines that are developed with public funds, and to agree on rules to collaborate on sharing vaccines equitably when demand is high,” said Dr Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus, director-general of WHO, speaking about the report at a press conference on Wednesday. 

The 2022 annual report is the first report to include the impact of Covid-19 pandemic on the global vaccine production and supply chain. The report is also viewed as a guiding tool to achieve the WHO’s goals of the Immunization Agenda 2030 that was adopted at the World Health Assembly 2021. 

The Immunization Agenda 2030 targets to save 50 million lives over the next decade by improving access to vaccines to everyone across the world. 

Governments need to invest and bear risks

“Diseases such as hookworm, schistosomiasis and leishmaniasis, and pathogens prioritized by the WHO R&D Blueprint, such as Zika, Lassa fever, Nipah and henipaviral diseases, Rift Valley fever, Crimean–Congo haemorrhagic fever and filoviruses, are still missing a vaccine,” the report stated. 

Vaccine manufacturing involves heavy investments upfront with high risks, the report noted. The profits that vaccines bring are also less than that brought in by other pharmaceutical products. In an attempt to mitigate these barriers, the report urges governments topport  measures that prime the market, such as ¨investing in new vaccine technologies, regional research and development and manufacturing hubs, and by enabling regulatory harmonization.”

Distributed supply is key

Although WHO has a repertoire of over 90 approved vaccine manufacturers across the world, a large chunk of the supply is concentrated in the hands of just 10 manufacturers, the global health agency noted. Around 70% of the vaccine doses come from these manufacturers. When it comes to individual vaccines, often, the supply may be concentrated in the hands of just two or three manufacturers, the report notes.  The resulting market concentration has led to supply shortages, as seen in the response to recent emergencies such as monkeypox or cholera. In the case of the latter, vaccine shortages recently led to WHO´s recommendation in October to ration supplies by administering only one vaccine dose, as compared to two.

“Each of the human papillomavirus, pneumo- coccal conjugate and measles, mumps and rubella combination vaccines is used by at least 100 countries, but each market is highly dependent on one or two manufacturers that account for more than 80% of vaccines by volume,” the report added. 

In the case of COVID vaccines, vaccine distribution was also mostly focused in the regions where particular vaccines were produced, the report notes.  As a result, regions without vaccine manufacturing capacity were left dependent on other regions to cater to their demands, often belatedly. 

Vaccine
Vaccine manufacturing and distribution pattern (WHO Vaccine market report, 2022)

So despite the fact that COVID vaccines were developed and manufactured in record time, parts of the world were left without access to vaccines for many months, since the technology and the production was centered in limited number of companies and countries, the report found. To remedy that, WHO called upon governments to strategically and aggressively invest  in more vaccine manufacturing capacity for the future. The report also urged governments to define principles and establish rules for collaboration, especially on intellectual property and sharing of raw materials. 

The report also urged countries to explore more pooled procurement options with other countries in their region, as compared to relying only upon national mechanisms.

“Compared to self-procurement, pooled procurement attains lower prices for 14 of the 18 vaccines most widely used in middle-income countries, the average price for all 18 vaccines combined being 42% lower, although differences vary significantly for individual vaccines,” the report found. 

WHO also called on the vaccine industry to align their research and development activities more closely with the WHO´s priority pathogen list and target product profiles, and to ensure there is transparency in their value chain. 

Free-market dynamics don’t work

A stark feature of this edition of the Vaccine Market Report is the emphasis on the need for governments to keep public welfare in mind when dealing with the vaccine value chain. 

Invoking the fact of vaccine disparities between wealthier countries and low and middle income countries during the Covid-19, relying primarily on market dynamics in vaccine distribution does not promote global public health goals, the report states. 

“We must acknowledge both that vaccines are under-invested and that free market dynamics do not optimize for social and health impact.” 

Pointing out that the WHO-supported COVAX vaccine facility´s share in the total quantity of vaccines procured and distributed globally  only 12%, the report emphasized that globally-managed financing and procurement efforts alone are not enough to ensure that vaccines reach everyone in all the corners of the world. In October, COVAX was criticised as having been too ambitious” in an independent evaluation of its performance as part of the WHO-supported Access to Covid-19 Tools Accelerator (ACT-A). 

“Despite the impressive number of approximately 15 billion doses delivered globally through various mechanisms as of October 2022, COVAX accounted for only 12% of this volume, indicating that serving all populations more equitably and ending future pandemics requires more than financing and procurement efforts.”

“The right to health means the right to vaccines,” Dr Tedros added. 

Image Credits: Mat Napo/Unsplash, World Health Organization.

From left: Maria Neria, Riccardo Puliti, Mamunur Rahman Malik, Harish Hande and Francesco La Camera at WHO COP27 event.

SHARM EL-SHEIKH, Egypt – The International Renewable Agency (IRENA), on Tuesday, said it would pump $1billion into a new effort that would electrify health facilities, along with food storage and agriculture, with solar power, while the World Bank said it also plans to triple its investments in solar electrification efforts to reach 100,000 health facilities by 2030. 

The initiative aims to tackle the gaps in health care that leave an estimated one billion people around the world reliant on healthcare facilities with either no electricity or an unreliable supply, IRENA´s Director General, Francesco La Camera.

He was speaking at a high level event, “Energizing health: accelerating electricity access in health-care facilities,” organized by the World Health Organization at its COP27 Health Pavilion. 

La Camera said that his agency is assessing the energy gaps in healthcare systems in a number of the poorest sub-Saharan African countries, beginning with Burkina Faso, Malawi and Mali in order to get a better idea of the gaps in energy access, and how they impede health service delivery.

A 2013 WHO-sponsored study of 11 sub-Saharan African countries found that 26% of health facilities had no electricity at all, and only 28% of facilities, on average, had reliable electricity access. Even at hospital level, only 34% of hospitals had reliable electricity.  Traditionally, the fallback power option for the health sector in areas with poor grid access has been diesel generators, which are not only highly polluting but costly, with fuel expense and breakdowns leaving a large proportion idle.  

During the pandemic, there was a major push to add solar powered refrigeration capacity to African health centers to roll out COVID vaccines, which require a reliable cold chain.  But there remains a lack of systematic investment, along with comprehensive data on gaps and needs on the ground. 

Francesco La Camera, director-general of IRENA

Even with the limited data available, however, it´s apparent that the lack of electricity and impacts on healthcare are particularly severe in Africa, agreed panelists at the event, which included representatives from the World Bank, WHO´s office in Somalia and a leading Indian solar entrepreneur. 

Their discussion focused on energy needs in healthcare facilities, the potential for shifting to renewable energy sources, and the funds needed for such initiatives.

“In view of the COP28, we aim to create a partnership with government, philanthropies, foundation trust, charitable funds, the World Bank and the private sector among other stakeholders, and naturally, WHO, to commit $1 billion towards the empowering lifts and livelihood, renewables, follow adaptation, initiative to connect people and livelihood through renewable energy solution in agriculture, food and health sectors,” La Camera said, of the IRENA commitment. 

World Bank also doubling finance to focus on mini-grids 

The IRENA initiative comes on top of an existing $1.3 billion a year World Bank investment  in renewable energy access for farms, schools and health facilities in off grid communities, said  Riccardo Puliti, the vice-president of the Bank’s infrastructure division. But of that amount, not more than $100 million goes towards healthcare facilities, he admitted.

Efforts to invest in healthcare facilities accelerated during the COVID-19 pandemic, he noted. In that period, the Bank developed and disseminated improved tools for facilities to estimate their energy requirements, so as to allow for the more reliable electrification of cold chains, and thus storage of vaccines. 

Riccardo Puliti, vice-president of World Bank’s Infrastructure division.

However, the Bank now plans to ramp up funding for community-based mini-grids, from which health facilities as well as homes, schools and other community functions, might all benefit. 

Mini grids are decentralized energy facilities that may involve solar arrays, battery storage and generator backup, and can be used to produce and distribute electricity within small communities that are too far removed from the grid to enjoy reliable service from conventional power supplies.  

“The idea is to provide mini grids for half a billion people and 100,000 health facilities by 2030. We plan to triple our $1.2 billion per year in order to achieve that,” Puliti said.

Learning from Nigeria and Somalia

Among sub-Saharan African countries, Somalia ranks as one of the most under-served. Some 85% of Somalia’s population do not have access to electricity. Only 28% of healthcare centres in the east African country have access to electricity and only 27% of the population can easily access healthcare, said Dr Mamunur Rahman Malik, WHO´s representative in Somalia, who also appeared at the event. 

The price of electricity in Somalia is between $1-$2 per kilowatt hour, while its neighbouring regions pay anywhere between $0.02 and $0.03. 

Calling Somalia’s plight a “social injustice”, Malik described how emergency surgeries and pediatric procedures are frequently performed under kerosene lamps or even in candle lights.

Inevitably, lack of electricity access also contributes to the country´s high rates of  childhood mortality.  

“A child who is born today (in Somalia) is 16.5 times more likely to die before the child reaches the age of five,” Malik said. “This is not the fault of the child, it´s because we don’t have health facilities which can provide health services. We don’t have refrigerators to preserve vaccines. One in seven children in Somalia is missing out on these lifesaving vaccines.”

Dr Mamunur Rahman Malik, WHO´s representative in Somalia, describing the benefits of solar electrification of health facilities in Somalia.

In January 2021, the Somalian health ministry, with WHO’s support, piloted a solar-powered oxygen delivery system at a government hospital in Galmudug. This has, in turn, saved the lives of several children who came to the hospital suffering from respiratory issues like asphyxia, pneumonia and accidents and trauma. 

Following this, the system was also set up in four more hospitals.  Then in 2022, the government  also began scaling up other solar energy systems to provide building-based electricity to 100 primary healthcare centres. 

Malik said that the reason why WHO supported the equipping of Somalian healthcare facilities with solar energy is because it is the most practical solution for a country that is arid and receives over eight hours of sunlight a day. 

Cost is also a crucial factor in this decision, he said. “A health facility or a laboratory spends $8,000 to $10,000 to pay the electricity bill (from grid services or diesel fuel based generators). If it is solarized, they’re going to pay only $30 just to maintain the electricity line, the electricity will be free.” 

He added that solar power will also help reduce medical waste of medicines and vaccines from poor storage conditions. 

Similarly, the federal power minister of Nigeria, Abubakar D.Aliyu shared his experience with switching health facilities to renewables in his country. 

The experience began when two health facilities in every district of the country, designated to receive vaccines, were equipped with solar energy.

The government also has equipped at least one million houses with solar panels over the past year, the minister said; the aim is to electrify six million homes by the end of 2023.  

“And I know it can happen. If we have a common will, if we have the will to do it, it’s gonna happen,” he declared. 

Intersectoral collaboration is key

While money could be an obvious barrier to achieving targets when it comes to the switch to renewable energy, it is more often the political will that’s missing, observed Harish Hande, the cofounder of SELCO India, a Bangalore based social enterprise company that has been deeply involved in national solar electrification efforts. 

SELCO India, in partnership with Ikea Foundation, has a target of installing solar energy systems in 25,000 healthcare facilities over the next four years. “If a very small organization like SELCO with 150 employees has taken a pledge to do 25,000 [facilities] with Ikea Foundation, the other institutions should do 20 times more. And by 2026 we should stop talking about solarizing of health,¨ he declared.

COP27
Harish Hande (second from the right)

He added that more efforts also need to be invested into harnessing the innovation capacity of the private sector – particularly in the design and manufacture of essential appliances that consume less energy. 

“We would lose out on an opportunity if we just look at this as an issue of electrification… It’s not about solar power. It’s a combination of innovations that will spur further innovation.” 

Meanwhile, La Camera stressed the need to put the necessary basic solar  infrastructure in place, which can then be harnessed for scaling up solar power. “Industrial sector should work in cooperation,” he said. 

And there is also a need to incentivise industries in the most underserved regions, such as Africa, to manufacture solar equipment at cheaper, or even subsidized prices. 

Puliti pointed out that unlike five years ago, solar arrays and batteries are affordable and competitive in almost any setting. 

In dense urban areas, more reliable grid-based power using a mix of renewable and non-renewable energy sources is the more likely short-term aim, he said. But particularly in sub-Saharan Africa, there’s a “huge urban and rural divide” with rural areas lacking any possibility to link to the grid in the near term. 

“In sub Saharan Africa 52% of the population do not have any access to electricity,” he said, adding that cities have an electrification grid of 80-85% in contrast to the countries like Somalia and Central African Republic with minimal access to electricity. 

“So we have to work both on, making sure that the cities get electricity, usually on grid, and then we develop as much as possible, all kinds of off grid…with batteries.  We must understand that solar and batteries are competitive with everything we can think of. Five years ago, solar was and batteries were not competitive. It is competitive now,” he explained. 

“Only by working together – states, financial institutions, institutions like IRENA, WHO, the civil society – (can we achieve this)..,” said Puliti. “This is different from 10-12 years ago where it (the cause) was mostly ignored. I have this strong feeling that we are going to overcome this by 2030, even though we are in the middle of a big crisis, we had a pandemic and all the rest.”  

Link here to the calendar of COP27 events on climate and health, and access to livestreaming from the WHO Pavilion in Sharm el-Sheikh.

Image Credits: Megha Kaveri/HPW.

COP27 plenary on Monday as countries make their case for more climate finance and better terms on cash received.

SHARM EL-SHEIKH, Egypt – Small island states and other African and Asian developing nations stepped up their appeals Tuesday for a reboot of the global financial system to make climate finance more affordable to their debt-ridden nations, now battling a rising wave of climate emergencies along with demands to “go green”.

Reducing interest rates on climate loans; shifting more climate finance from loans to grants; imposing a carbon tax on fossil fuel producers; and a fossil fuels ¨non-proliferation treaty¨  were among the proposals tabled by countries from South Africa to Bermuda and Pakistan to Mali, in the second day of high-level statements at the UN Climate Conference (COP27). 

“The oil and gas industry continues to earn almost $3 billion daily in profits,” said Gaston Browne, Antigua’s prime minister, speaking on behalf of the Alliance of Small Island States, whose very existence is threatened by sea level rise and extreme weather. 

“It is about time that these companies are made to pay a global carbon tax on their profits as a source of funding for loss and damage,” he said. “While they are profiting, the planet is burning.”

Loss and damage pledges inadequate

Mia Mottley, Prime Minister of Barbados, has set a trend for calls to revamp climate finance.

Meanwhile, a handful of rich countries announced about $60 million in initial pledges of aid for climate ¨loss and damage”.

Civil society groups immediately decried the pledges as woefully inadequate against the more than $1 trillion a year of actual costs for low and middle-income countries, ranging from flood-ravaged Pakistan to the drought-ridden Horn of Africa, and small island states devastated by increasingly powerful cyclones and hurricanes. 

However, just getting loss and damage on the climate agenda is “a significant achievement”, observed Mia Mottley, Barbados´ prime minister.

¨It recognizes that those countries such as ours, who have not contributed greatly to the emissions of greenhouse gasses should not be crowded out of our fiscal space in order to be able to finance the reconstruction after a climatic event,¨ she said. 

But she warned that ¨we will not achieve the conclusion of it¨ at the present COP.

The even bigger challenge involves finding new ways to finance climate actions that reduce, rather than add to, the already heavy debt load – including interest rates on that debt – of low- and middle-income nations, Mottley noted.

 ¨The reality is that unless our financial institutions can speak to the current realities, they will not be able to help us transition in this new way,¨ said the prime minister. 

She added that her ¨Bridgetown agenda¨ for financial reform, including an agreement with the IMF and others on a new ¨Blue-Green¨ finance facility to preserve the ecosystem of the Caribbean region with a 10-year interest moratorium, could provide one such model. 

 Remake global financial institutions or face millions of climate refugees

Phillip Davis, Prime Minister of Bahamas warns of a tide of climate refugees if rich countries don’t act faster.

It´s in the interest of rich countries to rethink finance arrangements on all fronts – mitigation, adaptation and loss-and-damage, added Phillip Davis, prime minister of the Bahamas. 

¨What is it worth for you, the world, to keep millions of climate refugees from turning into tens of millions and then hundreds of millions, putting pressure on borders and security and political systems around the world,¨ he asked. 

¨ I´m not telling you to overhaul the World Bank for this new climate era because it´s the right thing to do, I´m telling you to get smart and act quickly,¨ said Davis who also echoed a recent World Health Organization appeal for countries to agree on a  ¨fossil fuels non-proliferation treaty to steer our models towards renewables. 

¨Let´s get real about what is coming.  Let´s get real about what we need to do next,¨ Davis added. ¨We have no other choice… The alternative compels us to present ourselves at your borders as refugees.  The alternative consigns us to a watery grave.¨

Pakistan reeling from multiple needs 

Muhammed Shehbaz Sharif, prime minister of Pakistan.

¨Estimated damage and loss has exceeded $30 billion and this despite our very low carbon footprint. We became a victim of something with which we had nothing to do,¨ said Pakistan´s Prime Minister, Muhammed Shehbaz Sharif, speaking about the August flooding.

The flooding left nearly one-third of the country under water and some 33 million people displaced. 

¨Winter is setting in and we need to provide shelter, homes, food packages and medical treatment for people … for which we are spending billions of rupees from our meager resources,” he continued. ¨And at the same time we have to spend billions to protect people against other [future] floods and emergencies.

“How on earth can we do this on our own?¨ he asked. ¨Loss and damage needs to be part of the core agenda of COP27 to meet the pressing humanitarian needs of those that are trapped in a crisis of public financing fueled by debt, and yet have to fund climate disasters on our own.¨

South Africa – only 2.7% of aid from wealthy nations is in grants   

South Africa’s President Cyril Ramaphosa

Meanwhile, South Africa´s President Cyril Ramaphosa provided a tangible example of the problematics of green finance today – with reference to a new pact with Europe and the United States to support the country´s $98 billion plan for a  ¨just energy transition.¨ 

The deal, initiated at COP26 in Glasgow but only finalized on Monday at COP27, includes commitments by France, Germany, the UK, the US and the European Union, to provide some $8.5 billion in finance for the first phases of the South African plan.  The aim is to move the country away from its heavy dependence on coal and into green energy sources, including green hydrogen, as well as electric vehicles. 

Part of the financial package also will go to ensuring that coal worker and their communities – the people most affected by a transition – are not left behind. 

But of that support, only 2.7% is in the form of grants, with the rest to be made in ¨concessional loans and investments and risk sharing instruments,” according to a press release. 

And that is a big problem for debt-ridden nations like South Africa, complained Ramaphosa.

“Because South Africa already carries a fairly sizable loan burden, which it has to service from its fiscus, we require more grant funding,” Ramaphosa said, speaking in a separate press briefing. 

However, Ramaphosa expressed hopes that negotiations underway now could help shift that balance, creating a ¨real partnership,” as well as a climate finance model that other countries could emulate.  

“Industrialized countries … need to live up to the commitments that they have made, knowing full well that they – through development of their own economies – contributed a great deal more to the [climate] damage that many countries on our continent,” said the South African president.

Europe: Ambitious targets at home and new investments in Africa

Ursula Von der Leyen, ¨let´s earn the clean ticket to heaven.¨

The IPG investment in a green hydrogen facility in South Africa was one of several such announcements made over the past two days in this emerging technology. The European Union and Norway, meanwhile, announced similar partnerships with Namibia and Egypt. . 

¨The European Union’s additional renewable capacity is set to more than double this year, up to 50 gigawatts. And if we accelerate and if we scale up – and that is our plan – we can, in the next year, meet a new all-time record of over 100 gigawatts of additional renewable capacity,¨ said EU President Ursula Von der Leyen at the opening of the day`s plenary session, The EU leader’s comments also acknowledged, for the first time, need to talk about loss and damage. 

¨Because we know that every kilowatt-hour of electricity that we generate from renewable sources – like solar and wind, and green hydrogen – is not only good for our climate, but also good for our independence and our security of supply.

¨Here, the Global South has the resources in abundance. So let us team up. That is why the European Union is signing new hydrogen partnerships with Egypt, with Namibia and with Kazakhstan. That is why we are supporting partners such as Vietnam and South Africa to decarbonise their economies,¨ she  said. “Let us not take the highway to hell, let us earn the clean ticket to heaven.¨

And Norway´s Prime Minister Jonas Gahr Støre said that national climate commitments, updated since COP26 meant the Nordic country would increase carbon taxes to €200 per ton as well as reducing its own emissions by 55% by 2030, in line with the EU goal. 

¨We will fulfill our pledge to double climate finance within the next four years … and triple adaptation finance, with a particular emphasis on Africa,” declared Støre. He also welcomed Brazilian President-elect Lula da Silva´s ¨renewed commitment to the Amazon.¨ 

¨We also need to strengthen efforts to prevent loss and damage,¨ Støre added, almost as an aside.

Healthcare workers treat a patient with drug-resistant TB in Myanmar.

Two shorter treatment regimens for multi-drug resistant (MDR) tuberculosis have proven to be safe and more effective than the current treatment, the Union World Conference on Lung Health heard on Tuesday.

Results from Stage 2 of the STREAM clinical trial, published in The Lancet on the same day, show that a fully-oral nine-month bedaquiline-based regimen and a six-month injection-containing regimen have superior efficacy to the nine-month regimen currently used, which is a combination of pills and injections.

“Until 2016, the recommended treatment for MDR-TB typically included 7,200 pills and 240 injections and took up to 24 months to complete,” according to a media release from Vital Strategies, the organisation that sponsored the trial.

“In 2017, STREAM Stage 1 confirmed that a nine-month treatment regimen was as effective as the longer regimen. Now, STREAM Stage 2 has demonstrated that both a fully-oral nine-month regimen and a six-month injection-containing regimen have superior efficacy than the control regimen.”

Some 82.7% of trial participants had a favourable outcome using the oral nine-month regimen in comparison to 71.1%  on the nine-month regimen that had both injections and pills.

Largest MDR TB trial

The six-month regimen – which comprised of bedaquiline-based injections for two months as well as pills – was also more effective than the nine-month control regimen, with 91.0% of participants having a favourable outcome compared to 68.5% in controls. 

“While we are pleased with the performance of the regimens tested in STREAM and the evidence generated, there is still an urgent need to build upon these results and improve the efficacy and safety of MDR-TB regimens available,”  said I.D. Rusen, Senior Vice President at Vital Strategies. 

The STREAM Clinical Trial is the world’s largest MDR-TB trial ever conducted, with over 1,000 participants from eight countries. It was implemented by a number of global partners, including the Medical Research Council Clinical Trials Unit at University College London (UCL), the International Union Against Tuberculosis and Lung Disease (The Union) and Liverpool School of Tropical Medicine. 

MDR-TB is resistant to two key medicines, isoniazid and rifampicin, and is expensive to treat. Some of the treatments have serious side-effects including permanent deafness.

“It is particularly encouraging to note that the findings in the fully-oral and 6-month regimens are significantly better not only in the combined outcome measure, but also in the TB-associated outcomes, namely significantly fewer failures and relapses,” said Professor Andrew Nunn, STREAM co-chief investigator, at the MRC Clinical Trials Unit at UCL.

Professor Sarah Meredith, co-chief investigator and medical lead for STREAM based at UCL, also noted, “after careful monitoring of all participants in STREAM, we were pleased that no concerning safety signals were identified. In addition, fewer participants experienced severe hearing loss in the all-oral regimen (2%) and the six-month regimen (4%) compared to the control regimen (8%). This is important information, as hearing loss has been a particular concern for patients taking earlier MDR-TB treatments.”

Image Credits: The Global Fund / John Rae.

The World Health Organization (WHO) member states are currently negotiating a pandemic treaty to prepare for the next pandemic – but how can representatives of civil society have a seat at the table? What are the rules of civil society participation inside and outside decision-making spaces and what should they be? These questions were discussed during a panel organized by the Global Health Center at the Geneva Graduate Institute recently.

“Today, governments are assisted, influenced and challenged by a variety of civil society organizations, demanding greater transparency, inclusivity and accountability,” said Courtenay Howe, senior advocacy advisor at STOPAIDS and platform coordinator at Platform for ACT-A Civil Society and Community Representatives, who moderated the event.

How it worked in environmental sector

In order to understand what best practices can be implemented in international rulemaking, the panellists shared their experiences about the processes that led to other fundamental treaties in the field of environment, human rights and other sectors, such as the Basel Convention on hazardous waste.

“The Basel Convention is over 30 years old, so I would like to start with what happened at the very beginning,” said Katharina Kummer Peiry, director of Kummer EcoConsult. 

She explained that at the time the field was dominated by one very active NGO: “They were excellent negotiators, better prepared than most governments, and as a result, they almost had more influence than many government negotiators,” she pointed out.

According to Kummer Peiry, the organization focused on protesting outside of the building where the negotiations were happening, as well as “naming and shaming” the negotiators in order to demand change. 

“This has evolved over the lifespan of the convention,” she added. “There are now three categories of observers that are admitted through the process, civil society, which is mostly environmental organizations, but also social development organizations, industry and then academic institutions.”

Today, in the environmental field the goal is to have a variety of organizations involved and encourage them to hold  events and prepare materials for the delegates carrying on the negotiations, she added.

 

A universal right

“Participating in a decision-making process is a universal desire for everyone, but not only that, it is actually a fundamental human right, protected by international human rights framework,” said Saranbaatar Bayarmagnai from the United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights (OHCHR).

Bayarmagnai recalled the process of negotiating the Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities, which was adopted in 2006. It currently has 164 signatories.

“There was an intergovernmental working group established to develop and negotiate this treaty, and initially the process wasn’t as inclusive as we wanted,” he said. 

“There was a huge outcry by civil society actors in different regions and globally, especially by persons with disabilities saying that no decision would be made about them without them.”

Eventually, member states became more open and accepted to include organizations working on disability rights.

“They had a very meaningful and inclusive seat at the table,” Bayarmagnai noted.  “What happened as a result of that is that 75% of the legal text of the Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities came from those actors who were part of the process.”

Increasing participation in negotiations

In December 2021, the WHO established an Intergovernmental Negotiating Body (INB) in order to negotiate the legal framework for pandemic preparedness. 

Asked about what mechanisms have been put forward to ensure civil participation in the process, INB’s Co-Chair Precious Matsoso said making space for non-state actors was a useful tool.

“We are talking about an organization that was established through a constitution over 70 years ago, and this constitution is designed in such a way that the organization is rule bound, so we have to work within those rules,” she said.

“But I also think that the world has changed, it is more complex, more dynamic and more inclusive, so perhaps we have to look at how best we reform these processes,” she also said, adding that the attempt to involve non-state actors, despite some shortcomings, has resulted in a more open process.

Steven Solomon, WHO’s Principal Legal Officer, also offered his perspective on the ongoing negotiations for the pandemic treaty.

According to Solomon, these innovations were made possible thanks to the mandate of member states that participation should be expanded and deepened as much as possible.

The WHO official said that in his view, this mandate was due “to the level of confidence that member states had in relevant stakeholders in civil society, confidence in their commitment to constructive engagement.”

“It is remarkable to see what can be achieved,” he said.

However, there is still room for improving the mechanisms for guaranteeing civil participation.

Cedric Nininahazwe from the Global Network of People living with HIV (GNP+) suggested allowing more space for feedback and ensuring that information collected by communities reaches the relevant stakeholders in a timely manner.

“I think for the relevance of engagement and the information that people are providing, it will be great to create some feedback mechanisms where we can really engage on different issues,” he said.

During COVID, many community organizations were out in the field and they collected a lot of information.

“However, there is no way that this information can be shared,” he concluded, asking for a way to ensure that the data that has been collected reaches those involved in the negotiation of the pandemic prevention, preparedness and response treaty.

Mia Mottley, Prime Minister of Barbados, addresses COP27’s opening ceremony.

Europe’s attempts to get alternative gas supplies from African countries in the wake of Russia’s war in Ukraine are a “bridge to nowhere”, former US vice-president Al Gore told the UN climate change talks in Egypt, COP27.

“We must see the so-called dash for gas for what it really is: a dash down a bridge to nowhere, leaving the countries of the world facing climate chaos and billions in stranded assets, especially here in Africa,” Gore told the opening ceremony on Monday.

Earlier, civil society activists had also condemned the ‘dash for gas’, describing it as a short-term approach that was undermining Africa’s quest for renewable energy.

Turning Africa into Europe´s gas station

“European countries want to turn Africa into Europe’s gas station. They want to lock Africa on a gas pathway that will leave Africa with stranded assets, and leave the 600 million Africans who currently don’t have access to energy without the opportunity to power their future prosperity using the incredible renewable energy potential that exists,” Mohamed Adow, CEO of PowerShift Africa, told a press conference on Monday.

Gore also decried the short-sightedness of Europe’s approach to gas expansion in Africa, warning that it would “lock in” long-term dependence on fossil fuels. 

“We have to move beyond the era of fossil fuel colonialism. The dash for gas in Africa is a dash for gas to be sent to wealthy countries,” said Gore. He was referring to the recent spate of visits by European leaders to the continent to shop for gas to replace sanctioned Russian supplies – something that has reinforced the political will of some fossil-fuel rich African states to exploit their vast reserves. 

Instead of succumbing to those pressures, Africa should aim to become a ¨renewable energy superpower.¨ Gore added. 

On highway to climate hell

UN Secretary General Antonio Guterres

Meanwhile, United Nations Secretary General Antonio Guterres challenged COP27 to “agree on a clear, time-bound roadmap reflective of the scale and urgency of the challenge” to assist countries suffering loss and damage caused by the climate crisis, including “effective institutional arrangements for financing”.

“Getting concrete results on loss and damage is a litmus test of the commitment of the governments to the success of COP27,” said Guterres, who told the ceremony that the world was “on the highway to climate hell with our foot on the accelerator”.

Mia Mottley the Prime Minister of Barbados, said that it was time to reform the Bretton Woods institutions – the World Bank and the International Monetary Fund (IMF) – so that they could assist countries in the global South.

“The global North borrows with interest rates of between one to 4%, the South at 14% and then we wonder why the just energy partnerships are not working,” said Mottley.

“Similarly, we ask ourselves, if countries that want to finance their way to net zero and want to do the right thing can’t get the critical supplies, will they not have to rely again on natural gases to cross that bridge?”

Commending Denmark, Belgium and Scotland for accepting “the precepts and principles of loss and damage as critical and as morally just”, Mottley said it wasn’t enough for state parties to do the right thing.

“The non-state actors and the stakeholders, oil and gas companies, need to be brought into a special conversation between now and COP28. How do companies that make $200 billion in profits in the last three months not expect to contribute at least 10 cents on every dollar of profit or loss and damage fund?”

Ugandan climate activist Leah Namugerwa

Young Ugandan activist Leah Namugerwa said her ambition was to plant one million trees and bluntly asked the world leaders at COP what they were doing to address the climate crisis.

“If COP27 is to truly deliver, we must face some real truths.  We have had decades of inaction from all leaders, such as that the world is in a state of emergency because of fossil fuels. Africa contributes less than 4% of the carbon emissions while we suffer the most,” said Namugerwa. 

Debt burden hampering sustainable development

At a press conference before the opening ceremony, Tasneem Essop, executive director of the Climate Action Network, called out wealthy countries for failing to honour the commitment made over a decade ago to raise $100 billion per annum by 2020 for climate mitigation. 

“Vulnerable countries and poorer countries are reeling from the debt burden that they have to deal with. Much of the debt burden is also due to loans that they have to take out to actually address climate impacts,” said Essop, whose network represents over 1,900 civil society organisations in 130 countries.

“Developing countries are going through a vicious cycle of debt burden, taking out further loans and not having the fiscal space to actually deal with the developmental needs that they have in their own countries.”

Ahmed El Droubi, Greenpeace MENA campaigns manager, told the press conference that, not only had the $100 billion promised in Copenhagen in 2009 not materialised but that “approximately 70% of this finance comes in the forms of loans and further traps global South economies”.

Climate Action Network executive director Tasneem Essop and Ahmed El Droubi, Greenpeace MENA campaigns manager.

“The biggest issue of COP27 is the establishment of a loss and damage financial facility. This is long overdue, and is the greatest example of climate injustice that we see across the planet,” added Droubi.

Climate of ‘immense repression’ in Egypt

Essop also decried the “immense repression” of human rights defenders and climate activists in Egypt, with at least 60,000 “prisoners of conscience” being held in jails.

“There’s an overall trust deficit because of what I’ve just described – rich nations not fulfilling obligations – and then we also have a context in which, as civil society, we know that our right to protest, our right to assemble, our right have a voice, our right to have the right to dissent and hold power accountable is seriously and severely challenged in this COP being held in Egypt.”

British Egyptian pro-democracy activist Alaa Abd el-Fattah, who was sentenced for five years in prison in 2019 for “spreading false news”, and has been on a months-long hunger strike, announced that he had stopped drinking water as COP27 got underway on Sunday, setting the stage for a showdown over the human rights issue in coming days.

COP27
The line-up of speakers for COP27’s opening ceremony side by side before their keynotes.

As ceremonies opened in Sharm El-Sheik’s grand plenary hall on Monday, only one word came to mind in trying to sum up the scene: surreal.

World leaders paraded into the hall to music seemingly taken from a Star Wars film. The cast of speakers taking the stage consisted of a petro-state monarch, a friendly host cum authoritarian dictator, the UN Secretary General, a few academics, a young student, and the heads of state of Barbados and Senegal, sat side by side on white leather armchairs straight out of a first class airplane cabin. 

Set against the backdrop of an existential cross-roads in the global fight against climate change and the Egyptian government’s efforts to gloss over its human rights record, COP27 is off to a complicated start. 

Appearances a focus for Egyptian government amid human rights criticisms

Sharm El-Sheikh
Egyptian President Abdel Fattah el-Sisi takes the stage to deliver his opening address.

The road to COP27 has not been easy for President Abdel Fattah el-Sisi’s public relations department. Like Qatar’s efforts to use its position as host of the FIFA World Cup this winter to better its image on the international stage, Egypt’s plans have backfired.

The video that opened the ceremony – complete with cheering children, highly saturated shots of beautiful Egyptian coastlines, and a smiling cast of happy-go-lucky characters welcoming delegates to the country – was more a tourism advertisement than a call to action. 

And the sight of President Sisi cheering as the screen faded to black was eerie to any observer aware of the subtext behind the choreography: Egypt is, by any metric, a police state.

Cop27
Scenes from the opening video played before President Sisi’s speech.

Ten years after the revolution in Tahrir Square, Reporters Without Borders (RSF) ranked Egypt 166th out of 180 countries in its World Press Freedom Index. Since Sisi took power in 2013, over 100 journalists have been imprisoned.

“Abdel Fattah el-Sisi’s government has muzzled the country’s journalists and media,” said Sabrina Bennoui, the head of RSF’s Middle East desk. “Journalists can no longer say what they think and have no choice but to repeat the official line or risk being jailed for threatening the state’s stability.”

Sisi’s government moved to release dozens of high-profile political prisoners ahead of COP27 in an attempt to soften its image. But 19 journalists remain behind bars – making Egypt one of the world’s biggest jailers of journalists. And the fate of one activist, the British-Egyptian blogger Alaa Abdel Fattah who on Sunday racheted up his prolonged hunger strike, has focused the international spotlight on the human rights issue.

No word on Alaa, King Charles address mysteriously scrapped

Alaa
Alaa Abd El-Fatah speaking to Al Jazeera in 2011 amid the uprising against the government of Hosni Mubarak.

Abd El Fattah rose to prominence as one of the faces of Egypt’s 2011 uprising. After Sisi came to power, he became a vocal critic of the regime’s use of military trials for civilians taking part in protests or speaking out against the government. Today, military trials for civilians continue to be allowed under Egypt’s 2014 Constitution.

He is currently serving a sentence handed down in 2019 for “joining a terrorist group” and “spreading fake news” in a manner threatening to national security. Human rights lawyer Mohamed al-Baqer, who represented Abd El Fattah, was prosecuted as part of the same case after authorities detained him when he showed up to represent his client. 

“After Sisi came to power, the whole country was forced to shut up,” Sanaa Seif, Abd El Fattah’s younger sister and three time political prisoner told the European Parliament’s sub-committee on Human Rights in the run up to COP27. “As an Egyptian there is no way, not in my wildest dreams, that I could imagine a local climate activist raising concerns at COP27. Not because they wouldn’t want to, but because they can’t.”

Alaa
Alaa’s two sisters, Mona and Sanaa, stage a protest for his release outside the British Foreign Office in London.

Abd El Fattah has been on hunger strike since April and began refusing water on Sunday as the curtains lifted on COP27. Without food or water, he is expected to be able to survive just a few days. 

“The only reason I am able to address these concerns is firstly because we are not having this conversation in Egypt, and secondly because I am already doomed with the label of human rights activist,” Ms. Seif told the Parliament. “I have served three prison sentences and my brother is in jail, I have nothing to lose.”

Given the hunger striker´s British citizenship, the question of whether King Charles, who was slated to speak via video address, would bring up Abd El Fattah’s case loomed large over the opening ceremony.

But despite being listed as one of the key speakers, no speech by the British monarch was screened. Who made the decision to postpone or axe King Charles’s comments – or whether the King or Prime Minister Rishi Sunak might still address the COP27 in tomorrow´s high-level segment – remains unclear. 

Well-aware of the dangers to her own freedom, Ms. Seif arrived in Egypt on Sunday night. “I am here to shed light on my brother’s case and save him,” she told a sea of cameras as she reached the conference grounds. “Today he took his last glass of water, so it’s now a matter of hours.”

Sharm El-Sheikh as a symbol: no room for civil society

Sharm el-Sheikh
Sharm El-Sheikh has long been used by the Egyptian elite to escape public scrutiny due to its isolated location.

The history of Sharm El-Sheikh is emblematic of the contradictions underpinning Egypt’s hosting of COP27. The purpose built resort town is a six-hour drive from the 22 million citizens of Cairo, and its isolated location allows Egyptian authorities to tightly control who can get close to, let alone enter, the site of the conference. 

In the week leading up to the COP27, authorities detained an Indian climate activist walking from the capital to Sharm El-Sheikh for holding a banner that said “March For Our Planet”. He and his lawyer were released some 24-hours later, but the story reflects the value of Sharm el-Sheikh’s fortress-like status in quelling official’s fears over potential civil society demonstrations around the conference. 

“Every Egyptian you will meet in Sharm El-Sheikh will be vetted or intimidated beforehand,” Seif told the European Parliament. “You need to have that in mind while going to COP27.”

When former Egyptian president Hosni Mubarak was forced to flee the uprisings of Tahrir Square in 2011, he came to his residence in Sharm El-Sheikh. When president Sisi announced plans to build “New Cairo”, a gated satellite capital in the desert outside Cairo, he issued the declaration from the very convention center currently packed with climate dignitaries. 

Over 2 millions protesting in Tahrir Square after Mubarak’s speech saying that he would not step down, February 11th, 2001.

“Sharm El-Sheikh is a dream resort where the government can exclude the majority of Egyptians, and invest huge amounts of resources to ensure that everything is under surveillance and their control,” Hussein Baoumi of Amnesty International told the Guardian. “It’s telling how the Egyptian presidency and the leadership view their ideal society, it’s a gated one without the masses.”

In response to international diplomatic pressure, a designated protest area was constructed alongside a highway far from the conference center. Without the presence of civil society, it will be up to heads of state and negotiators to remember what is at stake. 

“You cannot shy away from addressing the human rights crisis with the excuse that you are going to COP27 to talk about climate,” Ms. Seif concluded as she held back tears during her appearance before the European Parliament.

“The climate crisis is not about the planet, the planet will outlive us all. The climate crisis is about life on the planet. And if you are serious about caring for the planet, you need to push for human rights.”

Image Credits: Gigi Ibrahim, Alisdare Hickson, Rutger van der Maar, Jonathan Rashad.